City hero
PennsylvaniaFayetteville

Find and Compare the Best Real Estate Agents in Fayetteville, PA

Tell us about your home buying or selling needs and instantly see a personalized list of agents to choose from.

Takes less than 2 mins
100% free service
No strings attached

Featured Agents in Fayetteville, PA

Daniel Toomey profile picture
Era Jack Gaughen Realtor

Daniel Toomey

View Profile
11years of experience
Rhea Foust profile picture
Remax Realty Agency

Rhea Foust

View Profile
17years of experience
Shelley Layton profile picture
Re/max Realty Agency

Shelley Layton

View Profile
20years of experience

Compare 15 top-performing real estate agents in Fayetteville, PA

The Berkstresser Realty Group

Wayne Berkstresser

27 years of experience
56 sales in last 12 months
Serves Fayetteville

About

Look no further! In addition to my 27 years Real Estate experience and being consistently ranked in the top 5% among Franklin County Realtors in production, you will have the benefit of our team working for you!! My wife, Jackie, also Broker of The Berkstresser Realty Group was licensed in 1992. My assistant Christy (also Jackie's sister), has 18 years experience with The Berkstresser Realty Group. She takes care of the behind the scenes details... making your transaction as smooth as possible!! Also, Zac (our son) has been involved in our business for several years and recently joined the team as a full time Realtor working with buyers and sellers. When you are considering a Realtor, please note that we have the combined experience (over 75 years' worth), determination & commitment to move you!

Read more

Achievements

Top Agent 1996-2014

High School Diploma

GRI, REALTOR®

Business Highlights

1031 Tax Exchange, Buyer Representative, Farm/Ranch, First Time Buyers

Re/max Realty Agency

Shelly Ott

33 years of experience
40 sales in last 12 months
Serves Fayetteville

About

Shelly Ott is a Real Estate Agent in Fayetteville, PA with the brokerage Re/Max Realty Agency. Over the last 33 years we have tracked null MLS listings by Shelly.

Read more

Achievements

Penn State

REALTOR®, GRI

Business Highlights

Buyer Representative, Farm/Ranch, First Time Buyers, Lot/Land

Keller Williams Kesytone Realty

Jay Schmitt

Open 24 hours
15 years of experience
Serves Fayetteville

About

His top priority is meeting your real estate needs and serving as your go-to Adams County real estate resource. Jay works tirelessly to provide the information necessary to achieve your housing and real estate investment goals. As a lifelong resident of Gettysburg, Jay is deeply committed to his community and offers the local resources needed to make your move seamless. He resides in the Lake Heritage neighborhood and is an active member of the Homeowners Association, contributing to the finance and Lake/Dam committees. Additionally, Jay is an engaged member and instructor at the Gettysburg YWCA and a supporter of community fundraising events. Before transitioning to real estate, Jay gained valuable customer-focused experience working in his family-run local business, Carpetbraggers. He brings this customer-centric approach to his real estate practice, ensuring exceptional service for his Gettysburg clients.

Read more

Business Highlights

Buyer Representative, Seller Representative, First Time Buyers

Realty One Group, Golden Key

Donald Beynon

Open 9:00 AM - 9:00 PM
8 years of experience
20 sales in last 12 months
Serves Fayetteville

About

After serving over 20 years in Law Enforcement, Donald entered the real estate industry to use his community knowledge to help buyers and sellers achieve their goals. He is committed to providing exceptional customer service with effective, responsive communication and flexibility toward his clients.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Negotiator 2024
Trophy Icon
Top Sales Producer 2024
Trophy Icon
Sells Homes Fast 2024

Associate's Degree, WCCC
CRIMINAL LAW, 1995 - 1997

REALTOR®

Business Highlights

Buyer Representative, Farm/Ranch, First Time Buyers, Foreclosures
I have lived and worked in the Franklin County area for over 20 years.

Coldwell Banker Realty Waynesboro

Kimberly Mills

3 reviews
Open 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Usually responds in 1 hr
19 years of experience
Serves Fayetteville

About

For Kim Mills, one of the leading real estate professionals representing Franklin, Adams and Southern York Counties in Pennsylvania, it is a great honor to help individuals achieve their real estate goals as they transition to their next season in life, whether it is upsizing, downsizing or purchasing their first home. Kim also assists clientele in Maryland’s Washington, Fredrick and Carroll Counties, specializing in the popular Hagerstown area.

Read more

Achievements

Trophy Icon
Top Sales Producer 2024
Trophy Icon
Top Volume Producer 2024
Trophy Icon
Top Company Agent 2024

2021 International President's Premier

ABR, SRES

Business Highlights

Buyer Representative, First Time Buyers, New Homes, Seller Representative

We've introduced over 4,940,482 buyers and sellers to top local real estate agents in the past 15 years

  • R V

    "The service was great and the recommendation of the realtor was fantastic. The realtor was fair and honest he gave me a very reasonable selling price and follow the listing all the way through. The house sold within the first week."
    Rita V. from Tennessee / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • A C

    "I used the website to identify potential agents in the new city I was moving too. I ultimately went with one of the recommended agents and had a very smooth home buying process."
    Alexis C. from Iowa / Bought a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • R J

    "My realtor was very professional in every aspect of the sale. My house sold within a week. She called or texted me through out the whole process."
    Ruth J. from Ohio / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • S M

    "We found an excellent Realtor, who guided us through the sale and did an excellent job along the way."
    Steve M. from Florida / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J B

    "Very professional, we had a great experience."
    Jon B. from Wisconsin / Bought a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • S K

    "The agent you recommended was fantastic. He stayed in touch throughout the process. He kept us informed every step of the way. The sale was quick and couldn't have gone smoother. Would definitely recommend to anyone else and will definitely use in the future if needed."
    Stanley K. from Indiana / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J L

    "Great realtors. My home sold in five days!"
    Joe L. from Illinois / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • B W

    "My selected agent was very thorough, professional, and attentive to my needs. He was absolutely the BEST!"
    Bonnie W. from Indiana / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J S

    "Had issues with the title company, which agents handled."
    John S. from Arizona / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com
  • J H

    "We had a very unique situation... My sister and I live in different states and the house belonged to our deceased Mother... Service was great could not have been any better..."
    Joe H. from Texas / Sold a home using RealEstateAgents.com

Sell your Fayetteville home with confidence

Why use RealEstateAgents.com to find a top Fayetteville real estate agent

RealEstateAgents.com puts you in touch with the best real estate agents in your area given your unique real estate needs.

Only Top Agents

RealEstateAgents.com’s network covers the entire country and features top closers in every market.

Expert Recommendations

Our AI-powered, machine learning-backed platform leverages millions of data points to connect you with a custom real estate agent list.

Compare Real Estate Agents

Our profiles include information to help you compare agents and find the perfect local REALTOR®!

Contact Us to Find a Top Agent in Fayetteville

+ 1 (888) 586 2349

Mon - Fri, 6 am to 6 pm PST

customer support on phone
We can help you move forward in your agent search

Fayetteville Housing Market Report

Market Action Index

We are extensively tracking the housing market in Fayetteville, PA. Here are the strongest factors contributing to this score:

Fewer homes have reduced their offer prices
Houses are selling quickly compared to the amount on the market
70
seller's market
Buyer's Market
0102030405060708090100
Seller's Market
Real Time Market Profile

Median List Price

$345K

Per Square Foot

$186

Days on Market

139

Total Listings

22

Market Action Index

70

Median List Price

Thu, May 22, 2025

Median List Price
1 Year

We can help you move forward in your agent search